Prediction Engine Alternatives: How to Compare Sports Prediction Sites (2026)

A buyer's guide for any sports prediction or picks site, ours included: what to check before you pay, and how Prediction Engine answers each check with numbers you can look up.

The short answer. Whichever site you pick, judge it on its record, not its claims. Ask for a public graded record that includes the losses, a play rule written down before the games, sample sizes, a base rate, a price shown up front and cancelling you can do yourself. A site that promises profit or “locks” fails before you get to the numbers. We do not review other companies; this page gives you the checks and shows how we answer each one.

1. The kinds of alternatives

People who search for an alternative to a prediction site usually end up choosing between three things:

  • Pick sellers and tipster services. Someone tells you what to bet. The whole value is the track record, so the checks below matter most here.
  • Data and stats tools. Numbers and filters, and the picking is yours. Check what the data covers and how fresh it is; there is no record to check because there are no picks.
  • Building your own model. No subscription and fully in your control, paid for in time. The common trap is testing a model on the same games it was built from, which makes it look far better than it will be on new games.

Prediction Engine gives picks, like the first group, with the habits of the third: trained models and Elo ratings that put a probability on every game, with the graded record of each market published. How those models are built is in how prediction models work.

2. Eight checks before you pay any sports prediction site

  1. A public graded record, losses included. Can you see every pick the site counted, win or lose, without paying? A handful of screenshots of winners is not a record.
  2. The play rule written down before the games. Does the site say in advance which picks count (a confidence level, a tier) and grade exactly those? If the counted picks are chosen after the results, any record can look good.
  3. A record that is never reset or edited. Is last season still visible after the new one starts? When a model changes, is the old record kept and labelled, or quietly replaced?
  4. The sample size next to every percentage. Is the number of graded picks shown? Twenty picks at 80% is a streak, not a rate.
  5. Backtest and live kept apart. Is a number from testing on past games labelled as such, separate from picks published before the games were played?
  6. A base rate next to the hit rate. Does the site tell you what a no-skill rule would have hit on the same bets? In some markets most bets win anyway.
  7. The price shown before you sign up. Can you see every plan and what it costs before entering a card, including what happens when a trial ends?
  8. Cancelling you can do yourself. Can you cancel online in a couple of clicks, and is the refund policy written down?

One more, which is a filter rather than a check: no profit promises. Words like “guaranteed”, “lock” or a promised return on your money describe something no honest site can know. A good pick still loses often. A 70% pick is expected to lose about 3 times in 10.

3. How Prediction Engine answers each check

  1. Public record, losses included. Every graded pick counts on the performance page, open to everyone, settled on the final score the morning after.
  2. Rule written down first. Each market has one play rule (for example, the NBA moneyline is a play when our Elo gives one side 70% or more). Each pick is archived before the game with the number the rule reads, the grader counts exactly the picks that meet the rule, and the same rule draws the badge you see on the board.
  3. Never reset. The record is rebuilt from the archived pick files. When a grading bug is found, the grader is fixed and every archived day is replayed; no counter is edited by hand. Each new season starts at 0-0 and last season stays in a dropdown. When our NBA moneyline model changed for 2026-27, the previous model's 156-41 (Mar 12 - Jun 13, 2026) was kept under its own label and is never added to the new record.
  4. Sample size. Every rate shows its count. Under 41 graded picks we show the win-loss only (“so far”), with no percentage.
  5. Backtest vs live. The performance page grades picks archived before the games; test numbers are never mixed in. They appear in our articles, labelled as tests, next to the live record (for example the NBA moneyline model and NFL moneyline model).
  6. Base rates. Where most bets win anyway we say so next to our number: every NHL road +1.5 covers about two times in three, and big NBA favourites win about 4 in 5.
  7. Price up front. $19.99/month, $49.99 for 3 months, or $109.99/year. The yearly plan is paid at signup. Every plan covers the NFL, NBA, NHL and MLB, on the web site and in the iPhone app with the same account. Details on pricing.
  8. Cancelling. On the web, from Manage Subscription, at any time, without contacting us. Cancelling stops the next renewal and you keep access to the end of the period you paid for. If you cancel within 24 hours of your first charge, that charge is refunded automatically and access ends when you cancel (once per person; not App Store purchases). A subscription bought in the iPhone app is managed and cancelled in your Apple ID subscriptions. The full policy is in the terms.

4. Our graded record today

The moneyline and puck line plays for each sport, this season, as the performance page shows them right now:

NBA Moneyline (2026-27)63-15 (80.8%, 78 graded)

Elo side 70%+. Expect about 80% over a season, mostly because big NBA favourites win about 4 in 5. Not an edge.

NHL Moneyline (2026-27)51-26 (66.2%, 77 graded)

Elo side 62%+. Expect about 62% over a full season.

NHL Puck line (2026-27)108-34 (76.1%, 142 graded)

Road +1.5 at 65%+. Every road +1.5 covered 66.9% over 3,936 games with no model, so this is not an edge.

NFL Moneyline (2026)43-18 (70.5%, 61 graded)

Not a toss-up and 65%+ confidence.

MLB Moneyline (2026)71-52 (57.7%, 123 graded)

Model 60%+. The 2026 season is over; this is its final record.

Props and other markets are graded on the same page, each with its own rule and count. Read every hit rate next to its base rate: a high rate on bets that usually win is not the same as an edge, and we do not claim one.

5. What we don’t do

An alternative may suit you better if you want any of these:

  • NFL spreads and totals as picks. We tested them and they did not hold up, so NFL is moneyline only. Spread and total projections are shown for reference, never as picks, and their results are reported separately on the performance page.
  • Soccer. We have no soccer product and no soccer record. The soccer articles on this site are reference reading only.
  • Picks built from the betting line. Our team models never take a betting line as an input: they work from results, stats and ratings. Where a market has a line, such as a player prop, the line is what the projection is graded against, not something the model learns from. Price is never part of a play rule, and the graded record ignores it.
  • Profit claims. We publish hit rates. No return, no “units”, no promise.

College basketball has a reference section with ratings and a board, and no graded plays. MLB is in its off-season.

Check our numbers yourself

Every graded market, wins and losses, with its play rule and sample size. Then see the plans.

6. Frequently asked questions

What should I check before paying for a sports prediction site?

Eight things: a public graded record with the losses, a play rule written down before the games, a record that is never reset, the sample size next to every percentage, backtest and live results kept apart, a base rate next to the hit rate, the price shown before you sign up, and self-service cancelling.

What are the alternatives to Prediction Engine?

Broadly three kinds: pick sellers and tipster services that sell picks, data and stats tools that leave the picking to you, and building your own model. We do not review other companies. Run the same checks on any of them, us included.

How much does Prediction Engine cost?

$19.99/month, $49.99 for 3 months, or $109.99/year. Every plan covers the NFL, NBA, NHL and MLB, on the web site and in the iPhone app with the same account.

Is Prediction Engine’s record public?

Yes. Every graded pick counts, wins and losses, on the performance page, rebuilt every morning from the archived pick files. For example, our 2026-27 NBA moneyline plays are 63-15 (80.8%, 78 graded).

Can any prediction site promise you will win money?

No, and no site can. We publish hit rates, graded in public. A 70% pick is expected to lose about 3 times in 10. We make no profit or return claim.

How do I cancel Prediction Engine?

On the web, from Manage Subscription, at any time. Cancelling stops the next renewal and you keep access to the end of the period you paid for. A subscription bought in the iPhone app is cancelled in your Apple ID subscriptions.

The week ahead, once a week

Last week's graded record — wins and losses — and the plays for the week ahead. One email, no daily noise, unsubscribe in a click.

Educational content only. Must be 21+ and in a jurisdiction where sports betting is legal. Historical rates do not promise future results and no outcome is certain. If gambling is a problem for you or someone you know, call 1-800-GAMBLER or visit ncpgambling.org.